
How to Be More Confident Dating (Even If You're Shy or New to Online Dating )
Feel Invisible on dating apps? Learn how midlife men rebuild dating confidence-even if you’re shy, divorced or new to online dating. Real advice that works.
Let’s be real-dating today is nothing like it use to be. If you’re a Man in your 40s, 50s, or beyond, newly divorced or widowed, the idea of jumpimg into dating again-especially online-can feel frustrating, awkward and overwhelming.
As a dating coach who works specifically with midlife men, I hear the same concern every week:
- “I don’t even know where to start”
- “What do women want these days?”
- “I haven’t dated in 20 years- how do I compete with younger guys?”
Here’s the truth: Confidence is your edge. And no, that doesn’t mean fake bravad or trying to act like someone you’re not.
It means knowing who you are, presenting yourself clearly and taking small but strategic actions that build momentum.
In this post, I’m going to give you a straight-shooting guide to:
- Rebuilding your dating confidence from the ground up
- Showing up in a way that feels genuine, not forced
- Getting out of your head and actually enjoying the process again
And here’s the kicker- confidence starts before you even go on a date. It begins with how you show up online. That’s why, at the end of this post, I will give you access to free dating photo makeover and an opportunity to get your profile reviewed- by a coach who gets where you’re coming from and know what actually works.
If you’re ready to stop overthinking and started getting results, this is where it begins.
1. Confidence Is a Skill – Not a Personality Trait
Let’s clear something up: You don’t have to be an extrovert or a smooth – talker to be confident.
Confidence isn’t about being the loudest guy in the room – it’s about trusting yourself, even when you’re nervous.
If you’re re-entering the dating world after a divorce or loss, that confidence may have taken a hit. Totally normal.
But here’s the good news: confidence can be rebuilt – and often faster than you think.
Start here:
- Remind yourself what makes you a great partner – your life experience, stability, emotional depth, and loyalty.
- Think of dating as practice not pressure. Every conversation is a chance to learn.
- Focus on progress over perfection. Confidence grows through action, not waiting to feel “ready”.
💡Mindset reframe: You’re not starting over – you’re starting smarter.
2. Body Language That Sends the Right Signals
You don’t need to “perform” – you just need to look present and comfortable in your own skin.
Here’s how to show confidence without saying a word:
- Stand or sit upright, shoulders relaxed, chest opened
- Make steady (not intense) eye contact
- Keep your hands visible – don’t cross your arms or fidget
- Speak slowly and clearly, not rushed
If you’re nervous, slow your breathing. This tells your nervous system (and your date) that you’re calm and grounded.
Confidence isn’t about “alpha energy” – it’s about presence … and presence is sexy!
3. What to say (When You Don’t Know What to Say)
If you’re shy or out of practice, conversation can feel like a minefield.
But here’s the secret: you don’t need clever lines. You need curiosity
Ask good question. Listen. Respond with warmth. That’s it.
Try asking:
- “What’s something you’ve always wanted to do but haven’t yet?”
- “What’s your ideal way to spend a weekend?”
- “What’s something most people don’t know about you?”
Avoid rehearsed lines or trying to “sell” yourself. Confidence is quiet and curious – not overcompensating.
4. Show Confidence Online – Before the First Date
Most Confidence issues start before the first date – right on your dating profile.
I coach Men all the time who say, “Dating app don’t work”, but when you look at their profiles it’s no wonder women aren’t responding.
Ask Yourself:
- Are your photos recent, clear and showing the real you ?
- Does your bio highlight your personality and values – not just your job or hobbies ?
- Are you presenting yourself as confident, kind, and emotionally available ?
If you’re not sure… you’re not alone. And help is coming… read on.
Ready to Finally Feel Confident in Your Dating Profile ?
Let’s be honest: if your dating profile doesn’t reflect your real strengths, it’s going to hold you back – no matter how great your intentions are.
That’s why I created something to help.
Get instant access to my FREE PHOTO MAKEOVER Video – where I show you:
- What makes a profile photo instantly stands out (without being fake )
- The #1 mistake that makes great guys get ignored online
- Simple tweaks to show up confidently before you even send a message
PLUS… Want a feedback on your current dating profile?
You’ll also have a chance to apply for a free profile review with me, so you can finally stop guessing – and start attracting better matches.
Click here to get your free photo makeover + apply for a profile review
https://tinyurl.com/FreePhotoMakeover
Because confident dating starts with how you show up – and that part? You can absolutely control.
You’re not meant to do this alone.
With love,
Coach Krysia 💛
💖 Want more inspiration for your dating journey? Head to www.dateyourdestiny.com and grab your free guide to get started.
Elevate Your Love Life with Expert Guidance!
Drop me a line for Your Dating Questions … the tricky ones, especially!